
If I ever get accused of making up my mind about a movie
before I see it, I’ll point to
The
Amazing Spider-Man 2.
I desperately
wanted to love this film, even after and in spite of the disappointment I faced
with
the first film in the reboot franchise.
The Amazing Spider-Man 2 is
not a catastrophe by any stretch of the imagination; there are things it does
quite well, things that might have made the film an unqualified success, but the
parts that don’t work did impede my enjoyment enough.
Fraught over his promise to her father, Peter Parker (Andrew
Garfield) doesn’t know where his relationship with Gwen Stacy (Emma Stone) is
going, nor does he know what to make of his former best friend Harry Osborn
(Dane DeHaan) returning to New York to inherit his father’s company.
What’s more, Peter is still wrestling with
the mysterious disappearance of his parents all those years ago.
As Spider-Man, though, he knows that the
arrival of the demigodly Electro (Jamie Foxx) spells bad news for the city.
The Amazing Spider-Man
2’s greatest undoing is its obvious ambition; like an overeager patron of a
fifty-year buffet, director Marc Webb and a quartet of screenwriters load up
their plate with no fewer than seven running subplots, borrowing from wide
stretches of Spidey’s comic book mythology.
And like at any buffet, there are entrees that taste great and other
dishes that add only empty filler to the meal.
Let’s start with the bad news.
A lot of my complaints about the first film
still stand, particularly about the subplot regarding Peter’s parents.
In a film that has so much going on, a
subplot that has no direct link to the main plot should have been excised or
made more relevant; it does serve to tie up a loose end from the first film,
but it’s a conversation-closer rather than a motivator for the characters.
Furthermore, it’s the focus of much of the
film’s middle, which means that the plot of the film screeches to a halt while
Peter looks at computers until he finds the right file.
The Parkers subplot is the only thing that
Amazing Spider-Man 2 has too much of,
and it certainly interferes with the pacing of the film because nearly
everything else feels underrepresented and rushed.
While DeHaan is quite good as a Harry Osborn
vastly different from James Franco’s interpretation, the script pushes him
through one too many character transformations and then bails on him with the
knowledge that he’ll be back for another film.
Similarly, Foxx is – pardon the pun – electrifying as Electro, an
iconoclast whose hero worship collapses when Spider-Man forgets his name, but
the film shuffles him offstage so that the aforementioned computer scenes can
take precedence.
It bears comparison to Sam Raimi’s
Spider-Man 2, which juggled a healthy amount of subplots and struck
a commendable balance between Peter Parker’s angst and his superheroic struggle
against Doctor Octopus (played brilliantly by Alfred Molina).
Raimi knew where to draw the line between
plots and came out with a fantastically tight narrative; Webb’s is a more sprawling
narrative that feels inflated by the demands of producers who want to lay
groundwork for future films rather than let those films develop organically.
I don’t, however, object to the brief treatment of Paul
Giamatti as The Rhino.
His scenes are fun
bookends that get us in and out of the film rather deftly, and they’re cleverly
scripted to tell us exactly what we need to know about Spider-Man at those
moments.
He might be back for future
sequels, but if not this is a perfectly fine way for movies to acknowledge the
wider comics mythology without getting bogged down.
(See also Batroc in
Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Scarecrow in
The Dark Knight.)
One thing that
Amazing
Spider-Man 2 does especially well, though, is the relationship between
Peter and Gwen.
Perhaps because of the
real-life relationship between Garfield and Stone, these scenes are the most
genuine and the most compelling in the entire film.
Garfield is pitch-perfect as the tormented
teen, truly conflicted about the tension between his feelings and his dangerous
lifestyle; he downright masters the chatty Web-Slinger persona, too, giving
Spidey a New York edge to his wit that Tobey Maguire seemed to lack.
And Stone – well, you’ve probably read my
blog long enough to know that I think she can do no wrong, and she continues to
ace it here; we can feel her frustrations with Peter but also know from whence
those feelings arise.
And I’ve spoken well of Foxx’s performance as Electro, and
the scenes with him are honestly among the best in the film.
Webb, previously best known for his
eloquently beautiful
(500) Days of Summer,
proves himself a solidly capable action director to boot.
I’m not sure quite what to make of Hans
Zimmer’s dubstep-inflected score, but the action sequences in which the bass
line drops and Electro pummels Spidey are probably the best such scenes in any
Spider-Man film, realistic without a fanboy-tongue-in-cheek wink (as the Raimi
films always seemed to do).
Or maybe it’s
just that they’re set at night?
Either way, in these moments Webb gives us the Spider-Man
film we want.
And if the film had been a
little more focused on these pieces instead of pushing toward too many finish
lines, it might have even exceeded
Spider-Man
2 in the realm of comic book films.
But
your mileage, true believers, may vary.
Perhaps this is the future of the Spider-Man franchise, and I’m wrong
about its misdirection.
Maybe I’m
stubbornly clinging to a previous generation’s Spider-films, but I sense from
the critical reception that the problem isn’t with me.
I'm willing to be wrong - I want desperately to be wrong about this film, but the problem is that this
Spider-Man just isn’t amazing enough. It’s serviceable, but in a world where
Captain America: The Winter Soldier is
playing a few screens away, “serviceable” just isn’t good enough any more.
The Amazing Spider-Man
2 is rated PG-13 for “sequences of sci-fi action/violence.”
We have a lot of zapping, kicking, and
punching, with a little bit of burning and exploding; one character death might
be traumatic and certainly ups the angst quota for the film.
Come back on Wednesday for the Double-Oh-Seventh of the
month as Timothy Dalton makes his curtain call as James Bond in
Licence to Kill!